Warsaw Coin Store

If you’ve been searching for a coin shop in Warsaw, come to Coins Plus. Since 1972, we have proudly served customers across the Tri-State area. Our staff is made up of dedicated team members who are accomplished coin dealers.

The Coins Plus team has over 100 years of combined experience with rare coins, collectible coins, and more. They are recognized in the industry and regularly contribute to reputable coin publications and association meetings.

Coins Plus is more than a standard coin shop; we buy and sell rare coins or paper money, offer cash for scrap gold, and provide appraisals for your valuables. Come in for an in-store appraisal or call us to arrange a private appointment at your bank or home.

Paper Money Collections

Coins Plus is the go-to shop for all types of currency. We can help you buy or sell rare paper money in Warsaw, including:

  • Obsolete banknotes
  • Continental currency
  • Confederate currency
  • Large size notes
  • Large denomination notes

Our staff is available to help answer your questions and can point you in the right direction if you’re looking for something special to add to your collection. If you need to liquidate some of all of your rare paper money, we can help get your collection in front of the right buyers.

Rare Coin Collections

Coin collectors prefer to work with Coins Plus because we are experienced and knowledgeable about all kinds of rare coins. Whether you are starting a collection, growing your collection, or want to sell coins, stop by Coins Plus.

We have an extensive selection of rare coins in Warsaw. Our team is happy to help you find the perfect addition to your collection, including:

  • US coins
  • Foreign coins
  • Ancient coins
  • Proof and mint sets
  • Minted error coins
  • Confederate coins
  • Commemorative sets

Cash for Gold

If you’re looking to get cash for gold in Warsaw, look no further than Coins Plus. We accept almost anything, including:

  • Bullion
  • Coins
  • Gold
  • Silver
  • Copper
  • Platinum
  • Palladium
  • Scrap gold
  • Broken jewelry

In addition to metals, we also purchase stamps, bulk collections, and so much more. Everything we buy is purchased at a fair market value.


If you need a coin appraisal or help with evaluation of your other valuables, visit Coins Plus. Our staff has provided accurate appraisals for over 50 years. We are very knowledgeable in assessing the value of your items. In fact, we are regular contributors to the Redbook and Bluebook pricing guides.

Award Winning Numismatists

The managing partners at Coins Plus are dedicated to improving the coin industry. They contribute to notable publications, present at association meetings, and have received multiple awards.

Bradley Karoleff was named Coin World’s Most Influential Numismatists and the American Numismatic Association’s Best Coin Dealer in the United States.

Emmett Ey is a lifetime member of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association and a 40-year member of the ANA.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


Come see why coin collectors prefer Coins Plus. Visit us in Florence or call us at 859-371-1414.