Madeira Coin Store

Coin collectors looking to start or expand a currency collection need to visit the expert coin dealers at Coins Plus in Madeira. We have proudly served customers in Madeira and the Tri-State area since 1972.

Coins Plus is a trusted coin shop that provides top-notch service to customers looking to buy or sell collectible coins, get an appraisal for their valuables, or get cash for gold in Madeira.

Our knowledgeable staff members have over 100 years of combined experience in the coin industry. We are dedicated to improving the coin collecting hobby and helping our customers find the perfect coins to add to their collection.

Buy & Sell Currency at Coins Plus

Our coin dealers buy and sell coins every day so that we can offer our customers the best selection of rare coins in Madeira. If you have a coin collection or are interested in starting one, you need to stop by our local coin shop.

Staff members have extensive knowledge in the history of the collectible coins in our inventory. At Coins Plus, you’ll find some of the most historic and rare coins, including commemorative sets, confederate coins, foreign coins, ancient coins, and more.

In addition to our inventory of rare coins, we also buy and sell rare paper money in Madeira. We have a growing selection of some of the best paper currency in Ohio. You can find everything from obsolete bank notes to large sized notes and everything in between.

Cash for Gold

If you’re looking to put some extra cash in your pocket, bring your gold, silver, and copper coins to our coin shop in Madeira. We buy gold in every condition, including scrap gold and broken jewelry.

Coins Plus will give you a fair market rate for your unwanted gold. In addition to coins, we take bullion and ingot. If you’re not sure what your gold is worth, bring it in for an appraisal.

Coin Appraisals

One of the best things you can do is understand how much your coin collection is worth. Bring your rare coins to Coins Plus for a personalized appraisal of your collection. We’ll appraise a single coin or a large collection.

In addition to coin appraisals, we offer appraisals for jewelry, antiques, paper money, and other collectibles. Coins Plus offers both in-store and private appraisal appointments.

You are sure to get the best valuation of your valuables at Coins Plus because we have extensive experience in the collectible industry. In fact, our managing partner, Bradley Karoleff, contributes to pricing guides like Bluebook and Redbook.

When you bring your valuable belongings to Coins Plus you can trust that you’ll get an accurate appraisal. To schedule an appraisal with one of our expert appraisers, call our coin shop nearest you. There are two locations in Ohio to serve you.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


We have two Coins Plus shops in Ohio. Visit us or give us a call. We’re in Anderson, OH, at 513-233-2646 and in Cincinnati, OH, at 513-621-1996.