Batavia Coin Store

At Coins Plus, our dedicated staff members are regularly recognized for their work in the collectible community. Our coin shop in Batavia helps customers start and grow their coin collections. We have proudly served customers in Batavia and the Tri-State area since 1972.

Coins Plus is your best option for a reputable coin dealer because we offer a wide range of services. Visit us to purchase and sell rare coins, get cash for gold, or have an appraisal completed for your valuables.

Rare Coins in Batavia

At Coins Plus, we have the best selection of rare coins to help our customers easily grow their collections. If you’re looking to reduce the size of your collection, we can purchase a single coin or the whole collection. We purchase coins made of every metal, including silver, copper, gold, and platinum.

Coins Plus buys and sells bulk coins, commemorative coins, mint sets, proof sets, foreign coins, error coins, confederate coins, ancient and more. If you’re hunting for a specific coin to add to your collection, you must visit Coins Plus.

Rare Paper Money

Coins Plus helps collectors with more than collectible coins and rare coins. We also buy and sell rare paper money in Batavia. When you visit our local coin shop, you’ll see our inventory of large sized notes, Continental currency, obsolete banknotes, national currency, and more.

We love helping collectors find interesting paper money. Our staff of currency experts is a wealth of knowledge and can help you learn about the history of the various paper money in our shop.

Get Cash for Your Gold

Coins Plus is the leader for cash for gold in Batavia. We always pay out a fair market rate for your scrap gold, broken jewelry, coins, bullion, and more. Our shop also takes silver, copper, platinum, and palladium.

Appraisals for Coins and Collectibles

In order to determine the value of your coin or paper money collection, you should have it appraised. Our team of appraisers can evaluate your collection and provide you with realistic coin appraisals, jewelry appraisals, and more.

Expertise & Experience

The staff at Coins Plus has over 160 years of combined experience. Our managing partners have received awards, written articles in reputable coin publications, and are members of the best coin associations.

Managing partner Bradley Karoleff was named the American Numismatic Association Best Dealer in the United States in 2013. He’s a lifetime member of the ANA. He also writes for Coin World and has received many literary awards. Bradley regularly contributes to coin pricing guides like Bluebook and Redbook.

Emmett Ey is a lifetime member of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association and a 40-year member of the ANA. He also writes for coin publications and contributes to United States Tokens.

For over 50 years, Coins Plus has been the TriStates’ leading provider of rare coins and other collectible currencies. Stop into any of our locations today to take advantage of our professional and expert service.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


To buy or sell coins, arrange a private appraisal or ask questions about your coin collection, give us a call in Anderson, OH, at 513-233-2646 or in Cincinnati, OH, at 513-621-1996.