Cincinnati Coin Store

At Coins Plus, you can find the best selection of collectible currency while also getting help from our team of expert coin dealers when you want to expand your collection. Our team has over 100 combined years of experience, which enables them to provide you with unmatched expertise.

The Coins Plus team has helped Cincinnati residents buy and sell collectible currency since 1972. We provide in-store and private appraisals. When you visit our coin shop in Cincinnati, we can also give you cash for gold.

Accomplished Managing Partners

Coins Plus’ managing partners are industry experts. They contribute to the industry by joining numismatic associations, writing about coins, and giving presentations.

One of our managing partners, Bradley Karoleff. is a lifetime member of the American Numismatic Association. He has been named one of the Most Influential Numismatists and the 2013 United States Coin Dealer of the Year.

Another managing partner, Emmett Ey, is a lifetime member of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association and a 40-year member of the ANA. He frequently presents at the CNA meetings and was the convention chairman in 1998.

Both Bradley and Emmett have been recognized for their writing. They have published articles in some of the most notable coin collector publications.

Have Your Valuables Appraised

Consider having your valuables appraised, so you know what they’re really worth. Coins Plus offers in-store appraisals for various collectibles and valuables, including coins, gold, silver, antiques, jewelry, and more. In addition to offering on-site appraisals, we can provide you with a private appraisal at your home or bank.

Coins Plus’ professional team provides the most accurate coin appraisals and appraisals for your other valuables so you know the true value of your collection. To schedule an appointment with one of our appraisers, contact your local Coins Plus today.

Best Selection for Coin Collectors

You can find the largest selection of collectible coins and rare coins in Cincinnati at Coins Plus. Our inventory of rare coins changes frequently because we buy and sell gold, silver, and copper coins every day.

Our coin shop has a wide selection of foreign coins, US coins, minted coins with errors, bulk coins, and confederate coins, to name a few. Stop by today for help starting or growing your coin collection.

Shop for Paper Money

We offer more than just coins at Coins Plus. We have all kinds of collectible paper currency, such as large sized notes, fractional currency, notes of large denominations, obsolete banknotes, printing error notes, and so much more. If you have a paper money collection, come to Coins Plus to see the best selection of rare paper money in Cincinnati.

Get Cash for Gold

Coins Plus will also offer you cash for your gold. Regardless of the condition of your gold pieces, we are able to offer the best rates for cash for gold in Cincinnati. We accept broken jewelry, coins, bullion, scrap gold, and more.

Whether you have a single piece or a large collection, we’ll pay you cash on the spot for your metals, stamps, jewelry, and paper currency.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


We have two locations to serve customers in Cincinnati. Stop by or give us a call today! Anderson, OH 513-233-2646 Cincinnati, OH 513-621-1996