Middletown Coin Store

If you’re interested in collecting coins or paper money, you need to visit Coins Plus. We have proudly served coin collectors in Middletown and across the Tri-State area at our coin shops since 1972.

Our managing partners are coin enthusiasts who have over 100 years of combined experience in the coin industry. You won’t find more dedicated coin dealers than the ones at Coins Plus.

We offer a wide range of services at our coin shop in Middletown to meet our customer’s needs. Whether you’re looking to buy or sell rare coins, get a coin appraisal, or get cash for gold in Middletown, Coins Plus is the place to go.

Buy Rare & Collectible Coins

Coins Plus is the best place to go to find rare coins in Middletown. We have the best selection of rare and collectible coins in the Tri-State area. Our inventory changes regularly because we buy and sell coins every day.

Whether you’re looking to start or grow a coin collection for a hobby or investment opportunity, you need to see the best collection of historical coins at Coins Plus. Our staff members will help you understand the history of the pieces you’re interested in and choose a coin that will be the best addition to your collection.

Collectible Paper Money

Coins Plus is more than your average coin shop. In addition to coins, we have the best selection of rare paper money in Middletown. You can find everything from obsolete bank notes to large sized notes and so much more.

If you have an extensive coin collection, you should consider adding paper money to your collection. Paper money is just as fun to collect as coins are. Each piece has its own historical story to teach you.

Professional Appraisals

The appraisers at Coins Plus are some of the best in the business. They can provide you with the most accurate appraisal and valuation because they have over 50 years of appraisal experience.

One of our managing partners contributes to the industry’s trusted pricing guides, Bluebook and Redbook. You can feel confident bringing your collectibles and valuables to Coins Plus for an appraisal.

Visit any one of the Coins Plus locations for an in-store appraisal. If your collection is too large to move, call us to arrange a private appraisal. One of our appraisers will meet you at your home, bank, or lawyer’s office.

Sell Your Scrap Gold & More

Coins Plus will give you the best rates for your gold no matter which location you visit. We take unwanted gold, like scrap gold and broken jewelry. We’ll also buy your collectible coins and paper money.

If you have silver, gold, or copper coins you want to sell, bring them to Coins Plus. We’ll buy a single coin or your entire collection. We accept other valuables and collectibles, too.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


We have two Coins Plus locations in Ohio. Call us in Anderson, OH, at 513-233-2646 or in Cincinnati, OH, at 513-621-1996 to arrange your in-store or private appraisal.