City Coin Store

Coins Plus is the place to go when you’re considering starting a coin collection, need a coin appraisal, or want to get cash for gold in Goshen. Coins Plus was established in 1972 and has become the leading coin dealer in the Tri-State area.

Our team of managing partners has unmatched experience and knowledge about coins. There are over 160 years of combined experience between them. We can help customers choose the most interesting and unique coins to add to their collection. We also have extensive experience in appraisals, so you know you get accurate appraisals for your valuables at Coins Plus.

The best place to buy and sell collectible coins and paper money is our coin shop in Goshen. We always offer fair prices if you’re looking to sell us your valuables. Come into your local Coins Plus to see why we’re the best at what we do.

Appraisals in Goshen

The appraisers at Coins Plus has over 50 years of experience in valuing various items. We appraise jewelry, antiques, paper money, coins, and more. With our experience and expertise, you’ll get the most accurate appraisal for your items.

One of our managing partners, Bradley Karoleff, contributes to the Redbook and Bluebook pricing guides and is also a lifetime member of the American Numismatic Association. Here at Coins Plus, you can feel comfortable knowing your valuables will be valued accurately.

You can schedule an in-store appointment for a personalized appraisal, or you can request a private appraisal. For private appraisals, we can meet you at your home, bank, or lawyer’s office.

Collectible Coins

The best selection and rotating inventory of the rarest coins in Goshen can be found at Coins Plus. When you visit Coins Plus, you’ll find a wide range of coins, including:

  • Historic US coins
  • Rare confederate coins
  • Foreign and ancient coins
  • Coin sets
    • Commemorative
    • Proof
    • Mint
  • Bulk coins
    • Buffalo nickels
    • Silver dollars
    • Indian cents
    • Wheat pennies

We can help beginners start their coin collection and experienced collectors find a special piece to make their collection complete.

Collectible Paper Money

Coins Plus isn’t just the place to go for coins; we also buy and sell rare paper money in Goshen. We have the widest selection of notes, including:

  • Continental currency
  • Confederate currency
  • Error notes,
  • Large denomination notes
  • Large sized notes
  • National currency
  • Obsolete banknotes
  • And so much more

Whenever you’re looking for collectible paper money for your currency collection, come to Coins Plus and choose from the best selection in the Tri-State area.

Cash for Gold

Coins Plus buys and sells a wide range of valuable items. If you’re looking to sell your things for a little extra cash, take them to Coins Plus. Here are some of the items we purchase:

  • Scrap gold
  • Jewelry and diamonds
  • Gold, silver, and copper
  • Platinum and palladium
  • Bullion, coins, and ingots

Our customers always receive great rates when they sell their valuables to us.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


Coins Plus in Ohio has two locations to serve you. Call us in Anderson, OH, at 513-233-2646 or in Cincinnati, OH, at 513-621-1996.