Crittenden Coin Store

When you want to buy or sell your coins, paper money, or precious metals, you need to visit Coins Plus. Our team of coin dealers has over 160 years of combined experience. Their knowledge is unmatched!

Coins Plus has been the leading coin shop in Crittenden since 1972. We offer personal and private appointments for appraisals or the sale of your personal collection. Our team can also help you start or grow a collection of rare or collectible coins and other historical currencies.

Unmatched Experience

The team at Coins Plus is comprised of knowledgable coin enthusiasts and experts. Our managing partners are regularly recognized for their work in the industry and they contribute to the community by presenting and publishing in notable coin publications.

Bradley Karoleff is an award winning numismatist and author. He has been recoginzed as one of the Most Influential Numismatists by Coin World and the Best Coin Dealer in the United States by the American Numismatic Association.

Emmett Ey is also an accomplished numismatist. He is a life member of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association and regularly presents at CNA meetings. He was the chairman of the ANA convention in Cincinnati in 1998.


Whether you need a coin appraisal or have other valuables, the team at Coins Plus has the knowledge to provide you with an accurate value so you know how much your items are worth. We regularly provide customers with appraisals for the following:

  • Rare coins
  • Collectible coins
  • Paper money
  • Jewelry
  • Antiques

We offer both in-store and private appraisals. Contact us today to schedule an appointment with one of our appraisers.

Coins for Coin Collectors

If you’re looking for rare coins in Crittenden, you need to visit Coins Plus. Coins collectors love us because our inventory is always changing. We buy and sell all types of coins, including coins made from gold, silver, and copper.

Our inventory regularly includes foreign coins, US coins, coins minted with errors, common bulk coins, confederate coins, and much more. We can help you start or grow your collection when you come in to our Florence location.

Paper Money

Our coin shop offers more than metal coins and currency. You can visit our shop to find all kinds of rare paper money in Crittenden. We regularly have large size notes, fractional currency, large denomination notes, obsolete bank notes, printing error notes, and much more.

Cash for Gold in Crittenden

For the best exchange rates for cash for gold bring your pieces to Coins Plus. We exchange cash for gold no matter its condition. We take broken jewelry, coins, bullion, scrap gold, and more.

We will buy almost anything, whether you have a single piece or an extensive collection. When you visit Coins Plus with your metal items, stamps, and currency you can walk out with cash in hand.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


Visit the nearest Coins Plus in Florence or call us at 859-371-1414. We’ll happily set up an appraisal appointment and answer your coin questions.