Cynthiana Coin Store

Coin collectors looking to grow or reduce their collection need to visit Coins Plus. Our team has served Cynthiana and the surrounding area since 1972. The expert numismatists at Coins Plus have over 160 years of experience as coin dealers.

Coins Plus has a staff that’s dedicated to helping customers find and purchase everything from rare coins and paper money to complete your coin collection. We also buy collectible coins if you want to downsize.

Our coin shop also has extensive experience with appraising valuables. We have in-store appraisals as well as private appraisals. To schedule a private appraisal, give us a call and we’ll meet at your home, bank, or other secure location.

Buy and Sell Your Collectible Currency

Coins Plus has an extensive inventory of rare and collectible coins. Our team loves to help customers find missing pieces to sets, start a money collection, and expand their collection.

Visit our coin shop in Cynthia to find a special piece for your collection. Our staff will happily share the history of the piece you choose. We have everything from rare paper money to rare coins. Take a look at some of the currency we buy and sell:

Rare Paper Money in Cynthiana:

National currency

Confederate paper notes

Obsolete or broken banknotes

Continental currency

Printing error notes

Fractional currency

Rare Coins in Cynthiana:

US coins

World coins

Ancient coins

Minting errors

Bulk coins

Proof or mint sets

Commemorative sets

We Pay Cash for Gold & Valuables

Whether you want to put some extra cash in your pocket, need to liquidate items in an estate sale, or want to part with your collection, Coins Plus can give you cash for gold in Cynthiana.

We buy almost anything, including:

  • Silver
  • Copper
  • Palladium
  • Platinum
  • Scrap gold
  • Broken jewelry
  • Rare coins

You’ll get a fair market price and walk out with cash on the same day. We provide both in house and private meetings.

Accurate Appraisals

Our on site coin appraisals will ensure you get an accurate value for your coins. One of our managing partners regularly contributes to the Redbook and Bluebook pricing guides, so we are well versed in understanding what your valuables are worth.

Industry Leaders

The managing partners at Coins Plus are accomplished coin dealers and award winning numismatists. They have received multiple awards from various associations and they contribute to coin publications regularly.

Bradley Karoleff was named the Numismatic Ambassador by Florida United Numismatists in 2018. He was also recognized as the Best Coin Dealer in the United States in 2013 by the American Numismatic Association. Bradley is a lifetime member of the ANA.

Emmett Ey is also an active member in the collectible coin community. He is a lifetime member of the Cincinnati Numismatic Association and has presented at multiple CNA meetings. Emmett is also a 40-year member of the ANA.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


Visit Coins Plus at our location in Florence or call us at 859-371-1414. We’ll happily schedule an appraisal appointment and help you with your currency collection.