Hamilton Coin Store

Since 1972, Coins Plus has been the top coin dealer in the Tri-State area. We provide a variety of services for coin enthusiasts and collectors. Whether you want to start collecting coins, appraise your rare coins, or get cash for gold in Hamilton, Coins Plus is where you need to go..

In addition to the unmatched experience and knowledge of our numismatists and coin appraisers, we also have more than 160 years of combined experience in the coin dealing industry.

Whether you want to sell your valuables or add a special piece to your collection, you’ll find the best selection in our coin shop in Hamilton. Our prices are always fair when you want cash for gold.

Appraisals in Hamilton

With more than five decades of experience in appraising valuables and collectibles, Coins Plus can assist you with jewelry, antiques, paper money, and coin appraisals.

One of our managing partners, Bradley Karoleff regularly contributes to industry pricing guides, like Bluebook and Redbook. We ensure the appraisers at Coins Plus are knowledgable and experienced.

Bring us your valuables to get the most accurate appraisals in town. Your appraisal will help you know what your collection is worth if you ever want to sell it or have it insured.

Rare Collectible Coins

The best selection of rare coins is offered at Coins Plus. Our rotating inventory of rare coins is second to none. At Coins Plus, you’ll be able to find a variety of coins, including:

  • Bulk coins
    • Indian cents
    • Wheat pennies
    • Buffalo nickels
    • Silver dollars
  • US coins
  • Confederate coins
  • Coin sets
    • Proof
    • Mint
    • Commemorative
  • Ancient coins
  • Foreign coins

Beginners in the coin collecting hobby can trust our team to help them start their coin collection. We can also help experienced collectors find special pieces or coins their collection might be missing.

Collectible Paper Money

Coins Plus has more than collectible coins, we also have a great selection of collectible and historical paper money. In fact, the best place to buy or sell rare paper money in Hamilton is Coins Plus, where we have a wide selection of paper currency, including:

  • National currency
  • Continental currency
  • Confederate currency
  • Large denomination notes
  • Large sized notes
  • Obsolete banknotes
  • Error notes, and more

We offer one of the largest selections of paper money in the Tri-State area at Coins Plus. Our inventory changes frequently, so stop by when you are looking to start or grow your paper money collection.

Cash for Gold

You can sell and buy a variety of valuables at Coins Plus. Whether you’re looking to make extra money or you need to downsize a collection, bring your valuables to us. We buy and sell:

  • Gold, silver, and copper
  • Scrap gold
  • Unwanted or broken jewelry
  • Platinum and palladium
  • Bullion, coins, and ingots

Our team of highly trained professionals will assist throughout the selling process. We offer in-store appointments and private appointments in secure locations such as your bank or lawyer’s office, as well as in our office.

We Buy & Sell:





Rare Coins

Coin Collections

United States Currency

Paper Money

Gold Coins

Gold Bullion

Gold Bars

Gold Eagles

Gold Maple Leaf’s

Gold Krugerrand

Gold Jewelry

Scrap Gold

Scrap Silver

Silver Jewelry

Silver Bullion

Silver Rounds

Silver Bars

Silver Eagles

Silver Dollars

Morgan Dollars

Peace Dollars

Constitutional Silver

Items Graded By PCGS, NGC & PNG

We Buy & Sell Other Collectibles:

Baseball2 Cards

Football Cards

Basketball Cards

Sports Cards

Sports Memorabilia


There are two Coins Plus locations near Hamilton. Visit us in person or vice us a call. Anderson, OH 513-233-2646 Cincinnati, OH 513-621-1996